PLSE Archive

QC (quasigroup completion): n=70, r=0.8

IDGivenG5 ILS (CPAIOR2015, 30s) ILS (JH2016, 10s) CPLEX (IP)CPLEX (CP)LocalSolver
1-ILS2-ILSTr-ILS3-ILS1-ILS*2-ILSTr-ILS*3-ILS
1 3920 4731 - - - - 4765 4763 4765 4763 4758 4740 4762
2 3920 4740 - - - - 4768 4768 4771 4767 4764 4743 4763
3 3920 4723 - - - - 4757 4758 4758 4752 4749 4732 4753
4 3920 4733 - - - - 4770 4768 4769 4768 4764 4736 4764
5 3920 4737 - - - - 4770 4769 4768 4766 4765 4742 4762
6 3920 4738 - - - - 4769 4772 4774 4770 4769 4743 4766
7 3920 4743 - - - - 4775 4773 4776 4773 4770 4747 4771
8 3920 4737 - - - - 4770 4772 4770 4769 4767 4744 4762
9 3920 4724 - - - - 4763 4762 4762 4761 4761 4728 4754
10 3920 4732 - - - - 4777 4775 4772 4771 4768 4741 4765
11 3920 4737 - - - - 4768 4770 4766 4766 4761 4743 4760
12 3920 4744 - - - - 4774 4774 4772 4773 4771 4750 4770
13 3920 4734 - - - - 4767 4770 4770 4768 4763 4742 4764
14 3920 4734 - - - - 4766 4764 4764 4760 4760 4743 4761
15 3920 4723 - - - - 4762 4761 4760 4757 4753 4738 4752
16 3920 4732 - - - - 4770 4769 4769 4766 4763 4742 4765
17 3920 4738 - - - - 4771 4769 4771 4770 4766 4744 4767
18 3920 4731 - - - - 4769 4768 4767 4766 4764 4743 4766
19 3920 4727 - - - - 4764 4764 4764 4762 4759 4737 4760
20 3920 4733 - - - - 4768 4767 4767 4765 4763 4735 4761
21 3920 4742 - - - - 4776 4775 4778 4773 4770 4751 4776
22 3920 4732 - - - - 4770 4765 4769 4767 4764 4737 4764
23 3920 4733 - - - - 4768 4766 4768 4765 4763 4740 4763
24 3920 4739 - - - - 4773 4773 4774 4770 4767 4748 4770
25 3920 4733 - - - - 4765 4767 4763 4764 4759 4736 4759
26 3920 4739 - - - - 4773 4774 4773 4770 4767 4744 4769
27 3920 4727 - - - - 4773 4773 4769 4768 4765 4734 4768
28 3920 4732 - - - - 4772 4767 4769 4767 4766 4742 4763
29 3920 4731 - - - - 4763 4762 4762 4763 4759 4734 4757
30 3920 4728 - - - - 4765 4764 4764 4764 4764 4738 4758
31 3920 4736 - - - - 4766 4766 4765 4761 4761 4740 4760
32 3920 4726 - - - - 4762 4758 4761 4758 4759 4727 4750
33 3920 4731 - - - - 4764 4766 4767 4762 4761 4740 4759
34 3920 4733 - - - - 4769 4767 4768 4766 4763 4735 4766
35 3920 4738 - - - - 4771 4769 4770 4767 4765 4744 4764
36 3920 4720 - - - - 4762 4760 4756 4755 4755 4731 4754
37 3920 4725 - - - - 4757 4756 4755 4752 4751 4729 4751
38 3920 4734 - - - - 4767 4764 4766 4764 4762 4739 4763
39 3920 4725 - - - - 4761 4760 4760 4757 4755 4725 4755
40 3920 4740 - - - - 4767 4763 4768 4767 4760 4746 4762
41 3920 4729 - - - - 4763 4758 4760 4758 4759 4732 4754
42 3920 4727 - - - - 4765 4763 4763 4763 4759 4736 4761
43 3920 4721 - - - - 4755 4754 4752 4752 4750 4725 4753
44 3920 4738 - - - - 4779 4778 4777 4778 4769 4749 4774
45 3920 4726 - - - - 4759 4755 4756 4754 4750 4730 4753
46 3920 4727 - - - - 4766 4764 4767 4764 4761 4732 4766
47 3920 4725 - - - - 4764 4765 4767 4765 4762 4733 4756
48 3920 4726 - - - - 4762 4758 4762 4757 4756 4732 4760
49 3920 4731 - - - - 4768 4764 4766 4760 4762 4740 4761
50 3920 4737 - - - - 4771 4772 4771 4768 4766 4740 4764
51 3920 4740 - - - - 4769 4768 4766 4764 4764 4742 4763
52 3920 4726 - - - - 4764 4760 4760 4760 4757 4730 4755
53 3920 4719 - - - - 4754 4755 4755 4752 4753 4726 4748
54 3920 4724 - - - - 4770 4767 4765 4763 4763 4732 4760
55 3920 4733 - - - - 4761 4758 4761 4758 4756 4735 4760
56 3920 4744 - - - - 4772 4772 4771 4771 4768 4750 4770
57 3920 4736 - - - - 4765 4769 4767 4764 4760 4736 4761
58 3920 4721 - - - - 4759 4758 4756 4755 4752 4733 4751
59 3920 4726 - - - - 4762 4759 4759 4760 4754 4732 4753
60 3920 4734 - - - - 4769 4764 4764 4764 4764 4742 4760
61 3920 4732 - - - - 4767 4766 4764 4763 4760 4739 4759
62 3920 4738 - - - - 4774 4773 4776 4770 4771 4749 4769
63 3920 4730 - - - - 4767 4770 4767 4765 4760 4737 4757
64 3920 4731 - - - - 4768 4767 4766 4765 4765 4738 4764
65 3920 4731 - - - - 4768 4767 4764 4765 4762 4738 4759
66 3920 4731 - - - - 4769 4768 4768 4765 4763 4738 4768
67 3920 4730 - - - - 4769 4770 4767 4765 4764 4738 4762
68 3920 4729 - - - - 4761 4763 4760 4756 4755 4732 4754
69 3920 4716 - - - - 4757 4757 4755 4753 4753 4725 4746
70 3920 4734 - - - - 4767 4769 4766 4766 4763 4741 4767
71 3920 4726 - - - - 4758 4755 4757 4755 4753 4735 4756
72 3920 4731 - - - - 4766 4766 4766 4766 4759 4734 4762
73 3920 4728 - - - - 4769 4767 4770 4761 4763 4738 4759
74 3920 4733 - - - - 4765 4765 4768 4765 4764 4738 4760
75 3920 4722 - - - - 4758 4756 4758 4756 4753 4729 4756
76 3920 4734 - - - - 4766 4768 4767 4761 4754 4735 4757
77 3920 4734 - - - - 4766 4766 4764 4762 4759 4738 4764
78 3920 4729 - - - - 4766 4762 4763 4762 4762 4734 4758
79 3920 4728 - - - - 4760 4761 4761 4758 4752 4729 4757
80 3920 4727 - - - - 4763 4759 4760 4759 4757 4734 4755
81 3920 4728 - - - - 4761 4760 4760 4760 4758 4737 4756
82 3920 4745 - - - - 4780 4781 4780 4780 4775 4753 4777
83 3920 4732 - - - - 4771 4771 4772 4769 4763 4737 4773
84 3920 4734 - - - - 4769 4765 4767 4767 4764 4743 4763
85 3920 4729 - - - - 4764 4762 4762 4766 4760 4734 4761
86 3920 4729 - - - - 4767 4765 4764 4765 4761 4741 4758
87 3920 4731 - - - - 4767 4769 4769 4763 4763 4740 4763
88 3920 4732 - - - - 4768 4767 4770 4764 4764 4738 4762
89 3920 4733 - - - - 4771 4770 4770 4770 4766 4743 4764
90 3920 4731 - - - - 4770 4774 4773 4771 4768 4743 4767
91 3920 4721 - - - - 4761 4761 4764 4762 4761 4731 4759
92 3920 4733 - - - - 4772 4772 4770 4766 4762 4736 4764
93 3920 4725 - - - - 4764 4763 4765 4763 4760 4729 4757
94 3920 4736 - - - - 4763 4764 4767 4764 4763 4737 4758
95 3920 4733 - - - - 4772 4771 4770 4770 4769 4736 4765
96 3920 4729 - - - - 4765 4764 4764 4765 4758 4730 4760
97 3920 4728 - - - - 4765 4767 4765 4764 4762 4734 4760
98 3920 4739 - - - - 4771 4772 4772 4770 4767 4752 4768
99 3920 4733 - - - - 4770 4769 4768 4767 4766 4742 4770
100 3920 4735 - - - - 4768 4767 4767 4766 4763 4738 4761
IDGivenG51-ILS2-ILSTr-ILS3-ILS1-ILS*2-ILSTr-ILS*3-ILSCPLEX (IP)CPLEX (CP)LocalSolver
Avg. 3920 4731.35 - - - - 4766.67 4765.81 4765.91 4763.93 4761.44 4737.73 4761.17
Completion - 0 - - - - 0 0 0 0 0 0 0