PLSE Archive

QWH (quasigroup with holes): n=40, r=0.6

IDGivenG5 ILS (CPAIOR2015, 30s) ILS (JH2016, 10s) CPLEX (IP)CPLEX (CP)LocalSolver
1-ILS2-ILSTr-ILS3-ILS1-ILS*2-ILSTr-ILS*3-ILS
1 960 1581 1600 1598 1600 1598 1597 1600 1600 1597 1582 1589 1592
2 960 1583 1600 1596 1600 1596 1597 1600 1600 1597 1583 1587 1592
3 960 1584 1596 1600 1600 1598 1600 1597 1600 1600 1600 1596 1593
4 960 1588 1598 1600 1600 1598 1600 1600 1598 1598 1588 1592 1598
5 960 1582 1600 1600 1596 1597 1598 1600 1600 1598 1582 1586 1588
6 960 1584 1596 1598 1600 1600 1598 1598 1597 1598 1584 1586 1598
7 960 1582 1597 1600 1598 1598 1600 1598 1600 1598 1586 1585 1595
8 960 1584 1598 1600 1597 1597 1597 1597 1596 1597 1584 1588 1596
9 960 1578 1596 1598 1600 1598 1598 1600 1598 1600 1595 1590 1590
10 960 1584 1598 1600 1600 1597 1597 1600 1600 1596 1584 1590 1589
11 960 1587 1598 1600 1598 1598 1596 1598 1600 1596 1600 1588 1591
12 960 1585 1598 1600 1600 1598 1600 1596 1600 1600 1585 1588 1596
13 960 1586 1600 1600 1598 1598 1600 1600 1600 1597 1586 1587 1592
14 960 1579 1597 1600 1596 1598 1596 1598 1600 1598 1581 1589 1594
15 960 1585 1600 1600 1600 1600 1595 1600 1600 1598 1590 1591 1595
16 960 1582 1600 1600 1598 1596 1597 1598 1597 1598 1582 1587 1592
17 960 1584 1598 1600 1597 1598 1598 1595 1598 1597 1584 1592 1594
18 960 1587 1597 1600 1596 1597 1598 1600 1598 1598 1587 1590 1594
19 960 1582 1597 1598 1598 1597 1600 1598 1600 1597 1582 1586 1592
20 960 1584 1600 1600 1600 1597 1593 1597 1598 1595 1584 1586 1586
21 960 1585 1597 1598 1600 1597 1598 1598 1598 1598 1600 1594 1600
22 960 1584 1600 1600 1600 1598 1600 1600 1600 1596 1584 1588 1592
23 960 1585 1600 1600 1600 1598 1600 1597 1600 1597 1585 1589 1596
24 960 1586 1598 1600 1600 1597 1597 1600 1600 1597 1586 1589 1595
25 960 1588 1600 1600 1600 1600 1598 1595 1600 1598 1588 1588 1595
26 960 1583 1600 1598 1600 1596 1597 1596 1598 1598 1583 1583 1593
27 960 1588 1597 1600 1600 1600 1596 1597 1600 1596 1588 1589 1593
28 960 1581 1598 1598 1600 1597 1597 1598 1600 1598 1584 1587 1592
29 960 1587 1596 1598 1597 1598 1598 1600 1597 1594 1587 1588 1592
30 960 1583 1600 1600 1600 1600 1598 1598 1600 1598 1587 1593 1594
31 960 1579 1597 1598 1600 1598 1598 1598 1597 1595 1581 1585 1597
32 960 1578 1600 1600 1600 1596 1600 1598 1600 1596 1578 1582 1593
33 960 1585 1600 1600 1598 1596 1598 1600 1598 1600 1587 1586 1591
34 960 1584 1595 1600 1600 1597 1597 1598 1600 1596 1584 1586 1590
35 960 1587 1600 1598 1600 1598 1597 1600 1600 1598 1587 1590 1596
36 960 1583 1598 1598 1600 1598 1598 1597 1597 1597 1583 1583 1588
37 960 1581 1600 1600 1600 1600 1596 1597 1598 1596 1581 1591 1595
38 960 1580 1600 1600 1600 1597 1600 1600 1600 1598 1600 1585 1594
39 960 1586 1596 1600 1598 1596 1598 1597 1597 1597 1587 1590 1593
40 960 1589 1600 1600 1600 1597 1597 1597 1600 1600 1589 1597 1598
41 960 1584 1598 1600 1600 1598 1596 1597 1598 1597 1584 1584 1593
42 960 1581 1597 1596 1598 1595 1598 1597 1596 1598 1589 1584 1591
43 960 1581 1597 1600 1600 1596 1598 1600 1600 1598 1581 1585 1593
44 960 1591 1600 1600 1600 1598 1600 1600 1600 1598 1591 1594 1596
45 960 1575 1595 1600 1600 1597 1595 1598 1598 1600 1575 1588 1589
46 960 1582 1600 1597 1596 1598 1600 1600 1600 1597 1582 1593 1594
47 960 1582 1598 1600 1598 1597 1595 1600 1598 1595 1584 1586 1591
48 960 1582 1600 1597 1600 1600 1597 1597 1600 1597 1600 1595 1594
49 960 1580 1600 1597 1598 1597 1596 1600 1600 1598 1580 1588 1596
50 960 1585 1598 1598 1600 1598 1600 1596 1600 1600 1594 1593 1590
51 960 1588 1600 1598 1600 1598 1600 1597 1600 1597 1588 1590 1593
52 960 1580 1596 1600 1598 1596 1600 1597 1597 1596 1580 1582 1593
53 960 1583 1598 1600 1597 1600 1600 1596 1598 1597 1583 1588 1592
54 960 1583 1597 1600 1600 1600 1598 1598 1600 1597 1588 1584 1595
55 960 1583 1600 1596 1597 1596 1598 1600 1600 1600 1591 1586 1598
56 960 1584 1597 1600 1600 1598 1597 1598 1600 1598 1584 1587 1593
57 960 1586 1597 1600 1600 1598 1600 1598 1600 1600 1587 1586 1592
58 960 1583 1597 1600 1597 1598 1600 1600 1598 1598 1583 1583 1596
59 960 1580 1600 1598 1600 1600 1600 1600 1597 1598 1581 1591 1597
60 960 1583 1600 1598 1600 1597 1594 1600 1600 1598 1600 1589 1597
61 960 1581 1598 1600 1597 1595 1595 1598 1598 1598 1581 1588 1593
62 960 1582 1596 1600 1598 1598 1597 1596 1596 1598 1582 1590 1591
63 960 1577 1597 1598 1600 1596 1596 1598 1597 1595 1581 1588 1593
64 960 1583 1595 1598 1597 1596 1596 1600 1598 1597 1583 1584 1596
65 960 1585 1598 1600 1600 1597 1596 1596 1598 1600 1588 1589 1593
66 960 1579 1595 1598 1600 1598 1597 1598 1597 1598 1581 1582 1596
67 960 1580 1600 1600 1600 1598 1596 1600 1598 1595 1584 1585 1591
68 960 1579 1600 1598 1598 1596 1598 1596 1598 1595 1579 1581 1592
69 960 1580 1596 1598 1597 1595 1596 1598 1598 1598 1580 1580 1590
70 960 1577 1598 1600 1598 1597 1596 1596 1600 1595 1600 1586 1595
71 960 1580 1597 1596 1598 1595 1594 1595 1595 1595 1581 1582 1592
72 960 1582 1598 1600 1597 1597 1597 1597 1598 1597 1582 1588 1594
73 960 1580 1598 1598 1597 1600 1598 1600 1598 1597 1580 1587 1591
74 960 1580 1597 1598 1600 1598 1597 1596 1597 1597 1580 1588 1591
75 960 1583 1596 1598 1600 1597 1597 1596 1600 1597 1583 1591 1595
76 960 1587 1600 1600 1600 1596 1596 1600 1600 1596 1587 1587 1595
77 960 1582 1598 1600 1600 1595 1598 1600 1600 1598 1591 1586 1593
78 960 1586 1598 1600 1600 1597 1596 1598 1600 1600 1586 1586 1598
79 960 1578 1598 1600 1600 1598 1598 1594 1600 1598 1584 1582 1592
80 960 1581 1598 1598 1594 1597 1598 1598 1598 1597 1582 1585 1590
81 960 1585 1598 1600 1600 1598 1598 1598 1598 1598 1585 1587 1596
82 960 1582 1597 1598 1597 1596 1597 1597 1596 1594 1582 1583 1590
83 960 1583 1596 1597 1596 1596 1594 1595 1600 1597 1585 1584 1594
84 960 1581 1600 1600 1598 1597 1600 1596 1600 1595 1584 1600 1594
85 960 1583 1595 1600 1597 1596 1596 1598 1598 1600 1583 1584 1592
86 960 1585 1597 1597 1598 1597 1598 1600 1600 1598 1585 1590 1593
87 960 1583 1600 1597 1598 1596 1600 1598 1600 1598 1600 1586 1592
88 960 1584 1598 1596 1598 1598 1600 1600 1598 1596 1600 1585 1594
89 960 1586 1598 1600 1597 1596 1598 1598 1600 1595 1589 1590 1592
90 960 1583 1598 1600 1600 1598 1598 1598 1600 1600 1583 1583 1592
91 960 1584 1597 1598 1600 1600 1598 1600 1600 1597 1584 1587 1594
92 960 1583 1598 1600 1600 1597 1597 1600 1600 1600 1583 1593 1596
93 960 1584 1600 1600 1600 1597 1597 1598 1600 1598 1584 1589 1592
94 960 1580 1600 1598 1598 1595 1595 1594 1597 1598 1593 1582 1594
95 960 1578 1600 1597 1600 1598 1596 1598 1596 1598 1578 1590 1595
96 960 1585 1600 1597 1598 1596 1600 1600 1600 1598 1591 1589 1592
97 960 1582 1600 1598 1597 1596 1600 1600 1598 1595 1582 1582 1593
98 960 1582 1598 1598 1600 1600 1598 1600 1600 1596 1584 1587 1592
99 960 1585 1598 1600 1600 1598 1600 1598 1600 1600 1588 1589 1593
100 960 1580 1596 1598 1597 1600 1596 1600 1600 1596 1582 1587 1593
IDGivenG51-ILS2-ILSTr-ILS3-ILS1-ILS*2-ILSTr-ILS*3-ILSCPLEX (IP)CPLEX (CP)LocalSolver
Avg. 960 1582.89 1598.16 1598.96 1598.84 1597.44 1597.63 1598.16 1598.85 1597.41 1585.83 1587.54 1593.31
Completion - 0 36 57 57 14 25 37 55 15 9 1 1